Southlake vs Colleyville
DFW's Luxury Mid-Cities: Town Square Prestige vs Quiet Elegance
Southlake and Colleyville are neighboring luxury communities in the DFW Mid-Cities, both offering premium living between Dallas and Fort Worth. Southlake is famous for its Town Square, Carroll ISD, and Dragons athletics, while Colleyville provides a quieter, more private luxury experience with larger lots, mature trees, and Grapevine-Colleyville ISD.
Southlake vs Colleyville
Side-by-side neighborhood comparison for Dallas, Texas homebuyers
Schedule a TourSide-by-Side Comparison
Key metrics comparing Southlake and Colleyville for homebuyers
| Category | Southlake | Colleyville |
|---|---|---|
| Median Home Price | $950K | $750K |
| Price Range | $600K - $5M+ | $500K - $3M |
| Property Tax Rate | 1.96% | 2.00% |
| School District | Carroll ISD | Grapevine-Colleyville ISD |
| Walk Score | 24 | 20 |
| Commute to Downtown | 30 min to Downtown Dallas | 28 min to Downtown Dallas |
| Lot Sizes | 0.25 - 2 acres | 0.3 - 1.5 acres |
| Vibe / Character | Prestigious, town square lifestyle, championship athletics | Established luxury, private, tree-lined, quieter |
| Best For | Affluent families, Carroll ISD seekers, social lifestyle | Privacy seekers, established families, equestrian lovers |
Why Choose Southlake?
Advantages of living in Southlake, Dallas
Carroll ISD Prestige
Carroll ISD is one of the top-rated districts in Texas. Southlake Carroll Dragons have won 8 state football championships, and the district boasts near-perfect college attendance rates.
Southlake Town Square
This iconic mixed-use development features upscale shopping, gourmet dining, a luxury movie theater, community events, and serves as the social hub of Southlake life.
Dragon Pride Culture
Friday night football at Dragon Stadium is a community event. The athletics culture creates deep community bonds and a shared identity that few suburbs can match.
Brand Premium
The Southlake name carries significant real estate value. Properties command premiums simply for their Southlake address and Carroll ISD zoning.
Why Choose Colleyville?
Advantages of living in Colleyville, Dallas
Larger, Private Lots
Colleyville is known for generous lot sizes averaging 0.5-1 acre, mature hardwood trees, and a more secluded, private feel compared to Southlake's community-oriented developments.
Lower Price Point
At $200K less in median price, Colleyville offers genuine luxury at a discount to Southlake. Buyers get more land, more privacy, and often more square footage for their investment.
Equestrian Friendly
Colleyville's larger lots and semi-rural character allow horse ownership and hobby farms in select areas, a lifestyle impossible in more developed Southlake.
Grapevine-Colleyville ISD
GCISD is an excellent school district in its own right, with strong academics, competitive athletics, and a smaller, more intimate school community than Carroll ISD.
Which is Right for You?
Scenario-based recommendations to help you decide
Choose Southlake if...
- ✓ Carroll ISD and Dragon athletics are must-haves
- ✓ You want a vibrant Town Square social scene
- ✓ You value prestige and a recognized address
- ✓ Community engagement and events are important to you
Choose Colleyville if...
- ✓ You prefer larger lots and more privacy
- ✓ Quiet elegance over social vibrancy appeals to you
- ✓ You want luxury living at a lower price than Southlake
- ✓ Equestrian or hobby farm interests require acreage
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about Southlake vs Colleyville
The $200K premium for Southlake primarily buys you Carroll ISD zoning, the Town Square lifestyle, and the Southlake brand. If those matter to your family, it is absolutely worth it. If you prefer privacy, space, and savings, Colleyville delivers exceptional luxury at a lower price.
Carroll ISD ranks slightly higher and has more athletic prestige (8 state football titles). GCISD is also excellent with strong academics and a more intimate community. Both are top-tier Dallas-area districts. The choice often comes down to culture preference more than academic quality.
Southlake has historically stronger resale value due to the Carroll ISD premium and brand recognition. However, Colleyville also holds value well and has seen strong appreciation as buyers priced out of Southlake discover its qualities. Both are solid long-term investments.
Both are approximately 28-30 minutes from downtown Dallas via SH 114. They are also 20-25 minutes from DFW Airport and equidistant between Dallas and Fort Worth, making them ideal for professionals working in either city.
Southlake is largely built out with limited new construction, mostly custom builds on remaining lots starting at $1.5M+. Colleyville has slightly more new construction options but is also nearing build-out. Both cities focus on custom and semi-custom homes rather than production builders.
Related Pages
Explore more about Dallas neighborhoods and school districts
Need Help Choosing Between Southlake and Colleyville?
Key Insight: Texas real estate offers exceptional opportunities for buyers, sellers, and investors across four major metros. With no state income tax, strong job growth, and diverse housing options, the Lone Star State continues attracting residents from across the nation seeking value and quality of life.
Connect with a Dwellverse Dallas real estate expert who knows both neighborhoods inside and out. Get personalized guidance for your home search.